What does Piggy say was just an accident? Lord of the Flies, written by William Golding, is a thought-provoking novel that explores the dark side of human nature. One of the most controversial moments in the book is the death of Simon, a character who represents the voice of reason and morality on the island. Whether Simon’s death was an accident or murder is a topic of debate among the characters in the novel, particularly Ralph and Piggy.
What does Piggy say was just an accident? (Answer)
When the other boys kill Simon, Ralph and Piggy have different opinions about the nature of the incident. Piggy insists that Simon’s death was an accident, while Ralph believes it was murder. Piggy’s perspective on the matter is particularly significant, as he is one of the novel’s more rational and logical characters.
Ralph’s insistence that Simon’s death was murder stems from his belief that the boys deliberately killed Simon. He argues that the boys were fully aware of what they were doing and that they intentionally caused Simon’s death. Ralph’s assertion that the incident was murder reflects his belief that the boys are capable of committing heinous acts and that the rules of civilization no longer govern them.
On the other hand, Piggy takes a more pragmatic approach to the incident, arguing that Simon’s death was an accident. Piggy acknowledges that the boys did not intend to kill Simon but argues that his death resulted from a tragic misunderstanding. Piggy’s perspective on the matter reflects his desire to maintain order and stability on the island, as he believes that the rules of civilization can still govern the boys.
What does Piggy blame Simon’s death on in Chapter 10?
Piggy, unable to face his own culpability in Simon’s death, chooses to attribute the tragedy to a simple accident.
Was Simon’s death an accident in Lord of the Flies?
No, Simon’s death was not an accident in Lord of the Flies. It was a result of the boys’ frenzied state and their mistaking him for the beast during their savage dance.
Was Piggy’s death an accident?
Piggy’s death in Lord of the Flies can be seen as an intentional act rather than an accident. Unlike Simon’s death, which can be attributed to a combination of fear, darkness, and the boys’ escalating mob mentality, Piggy’s murder is portrayed as a deliberate and inevitable act on the part of Roger. The intentional destruction of the conch shell, which symbolizes order and civilization, and the subsequent throwing of a boulder that kills Piggy indicate a conscious choice to eliminate any remnants of authority and rationality on the island.
Who does Piggy say has cracked Chapter 8?
In Chapter 8 of Lord of the Flies, Piggy suggests that Simon may have “cracked” and decided to climb the mountain alone.
In the raid why are Piggy’s glasses taken but not the shell?
In the raid, Piggy’s glasses are taken because they hold practical value as a means to start a fire. The boys recognize that fire is necessary for survival on the island. On the other hand, the conch is not taken because its authority and power stem from the agreement of a united society. Without a cohesive group to acknowledge its significance, the conch loses its symbolic value and becomes irrelevant in the chaotic and fragmented state of the boys’ society.
Conclusion
Ultimately, the question of whether Simon’s death was an accident or murder remains unresolved in the novel. Piggy believes Simon’s death was an accident, while Ralph insists it was murder. However, the debate between Ralph and Piggy highlights the tension between the boys’ primal instincts and their desire to maintain a civilized society. Through this conflict, Golding suggests that the human capacity for violence and aggression is always present, even in the most seemingly civilized individuals.